[Date Prev][Date Next][Date Index]

RE: E-M:/ RE: / Massasauga Earth First! statement about the attempted ELF action at Ice Mountain

Now why would you suggest that? I have known Anne for almost 25 years and she may be the longest serving leader in the environmental movement and is very dedicated - I do not ignore her comments - I may sometimes differ in perspective but I never ignore.  So lets keep on topic - personal attacks are not necessary 

-----Original Message-----
From: Andrew Mutch [mailto:andrewimutch@yahoo.com] 
Sent: Tuesday, September 30, 2003 3:30 PM
To: Trigger, Grant R.
Cc: enviro-mich@great-lakes.net
Subject: RE: E-M:/ RE: / Massasauga Earth First! statement about the attempted ELF action at Ice Mountain

That's funny - I saw Anne's message. Maybe you chose
not to read it?

Andrew Mutch

--- "Trigger, Grant R." <GTrigger@honigman.com> wrote:
> Now that is an interesting word but in fact I did
> not receive any message from Anne - maybe Alex is
> screening my messages.
> So while an interesting word it is misplaced.
> -----Original Message-----
> From: David E. Allen [mailto:dallen@nmu.edu] 
> Sent: Tuesday, September 30, 2003 10:59 AM
> To: Trigger, Grant R.
> Cc: enviro-mich@great-lakes.net
> Subject: Re: E-M:/ RE: / Massasauga Earth First!
> statement about the attempted ELF action at Ice
> Mountain
> Once again Grant borders on prevarication (perhaps
> he actually did not read 
> Anne Woiwode's email).
> But as a reminder, Anne stated the Sierra Club's
> position on vandalism 
> quite clearly, including the Sierra Club policy
> statement.  Grant is wrong 
> - wrong - wrong.  Do I dare say, as usual.
> Dave Allen
> At 08:11 AM 9/30/03 -0400, Trigger, Grant R. wrote:
> >Content-Class: urn:content-classes:message
> >Content-Type: text/plain;
> >         charset="iso-8859-1"
> >Content-Disposition: inline
> >
> >Frankly I am waiting to count the credible
> organizations that denounce ELF 
> >and ANYONE who has the audacity to endorse such
> tactics. Maybe we should 
> >be slicing the tires of any hunter who dares shoot
> an animal, maybe we 
> >should put spikes in the road to stop anyone who
> does not leave enough 
> >room to pass a bicycle, maybe we should put barbed
> wire at about 3 feet 
> >off the gropund on ORV and snowmobile trails - this
> whole discourse should 
> >disgust a normal human being.
> >
> >A ruleless society is a lawless disrespectful
> society and for those who 
> >desire and ecourage defying the law - they should
> move to a country that 
> >embraces a lawless society.
> >
> >As to this issue - Michigan is a net importer of
> water - just check the 
> >facts  - also where do you think the water came
> from that was used to make 
> >and export Stroh's beer and Vernor's ginger ale?
> And Frankenmuth 
> >ale?   Where did the water come from used to can
> vegetables from the 
> >Thumb?  Where did the water come from in the
> radiater of your car?  Could 
> >Ice Mountain bottle water from Lake Huron and be
> less a fiend?
> >
> >First amendment is one thing encouraging actions
> designed to destroy and 
> >put terror in the heart are another
> >
> >Anne - I invite the Sierra Club denounce these
> actions - taking a position 
> >on an issue and endorsing these actions are two
> different things.
> >
> >
> >
> >-----Original Message-----
> >From: Massasauga EF [mailto:massasaugaef@yahoo.com]
> >Sent: Tuesday, September 30, 2003 12:45 AM
> >To: enviro-mich@great-lakes.net
> >Subject: E-M:/ Massasauga Earth First! statement
> about the attempted ELF 
> >action at Ice Mountain
> >
> >
> >Enviro-Mich message from Massasauga EF
> <massasaugaef@yahoo.com>
> >
> >Earth First! Applauds the Earth Liberation Front's
> >Attempt to Damage Ice Mountain's Pumping Station
> >
> >Early last week, the media reported that there had
> >been an attempt to destroy or damage the Ice
> Mountain
> >pumping station in Mecosta County, MI. Later in the
> >week, the ELF took credit for the attempt. They
> cited
> >reasons of Ice Mountain's continued theft of water
> >from Michigan. Massasauga Earth First! would like
> to
> >commend the member(s) of the ELF who made this
> >attempt.
> >
> >Massasauga Earth First!'s position is that there is
> no
> >acceptable option but to shut down the Ice Mountain
> >plant.  Water is too sacred to allow greedy
> profiteers
> >to turn it into a commodity.  If we lose this
> battle,
> >then we have lost control of the most basic
> necessity
> >of life. Massasauga Earth First! is dedicated to
> >endorsing and promoting all public and non-violent
> >actions to shut down the plant and educate the
> public
> >about the consequences of water privatization.
> Earth
> >First! also realizes that corporations rarely if
> ever
> >give up their ill-gotten profits easily. That is
> why
> >we recognize the need for an underground resistance
> >that will take action to destroy the profit motive
> for
> >environmental devastation, actions that we cannot
> take
> >as above- ground activists.
> >
> >Brendan O'Rourke shed  crocodile tears in the media
> >last week when he "emotionally" spoke of the
> workers
> >"way of life" being jeopardized by the ELF's
> actions
> >and intentions. Seeing how Ice Mountain has only
> been
> >operating for a year and a half, and is the first
> >large scale water bottling plant in Michigan, it is
> >hard to see how anyone's job at the plant is a "way
> of
> >life."  Furthermore, O'Rourke is not crying about
> the
> >Ice Mountain employees who are losing their 'way of
> >life' in Pennsylvania due to the corporation's
> >overreaching exploitation that shut down their
> >operations there. His attempt to make those opposed
> to
> >the water bottling plant feel guilty for their
> beliefs
> >is transparent and despicable. No one should feel
> that
> >it is inappropriate to protect water for
> themselves,
> >their communities, and for the Earth. Our right to
> >water supercedes any corporations right to seize
> the
> >water and hold it for ransom.
> >
> >We would also like to address the issue of calling
> the
> >ELF "terrorists". The word "terrorist" is a
> >politically charged word. It invokes all kinds of
> >fears, stereotypes and horrible pictures in one's
> >mind. Those in power often us it to discredit
> >opposition movements. Predictably, Ice Mountain has
> >used the word extensively when talking about the
> ELF.
> >But the truth is that terrorism has a specific and
> >accepted definition. Terrorists inflict intentional
> >violence upon random people and other creatures,
> >creating fear and general anxiety. The ELF is not a
> >terrorist organization nor is it a violent
> >organization. They have never hurt, killed or
> nearly
> >missed hurting or killing anyone in any of their
> >actions in this country from 1997 to the present.
> >According to their published guidelines, they take
> all
> >necessary precautions to avoid harming any life,
> human
> >or non-human. Violence can only be done to living
> >beings, not property. The correct term to describe
> >their actions is "ecotage". Ecotage is an act
> against
> >property to diminish the profit of a company or a
> >practice that threatens the environment. It is a
> >strategy used as a response to an extreme case of
> >environmental exploitation. Every day that the Ice
> >Mountain facility pumps 400 gallons per minute out
> of
> >a negligibly rechargeable aquifer, irrevocable
> damage
> >is done to the local ecosystem. Every day that Ice
> >Mountain is allowed to operate, the damaging
> precedent
=== message truncated ===

Do you Yahoo!?
The New Yahoo! Shopping - with improved product search

Confidential:  This electronic message and all contents
contain information from the law firm of Honigman Miller
Schwartz and Cohn LLP which may be privileged,
confidential or otherwise protected from disclosure.
The information is intended to be for the addressee
only.  If you are not the addressee, any disclosure, copy,
distribution or use of the contents of this message is
prohibited.  If you have received this electronic message
in error, please notify us immediately (313.465.7000)
and destroy the original message and all copies.