[Date Prev][Date Next][Date Index]

Re: E-M:/ MI subsidizes egg laying CAFO, while Oklahoma AG Sues whole Poultry CAFO industry

Jan and Anne,

Converting "chicken waste" to "energy" could be one to two things.

If the CAFO is using a dry litter process, the chicken manure/wood chip combination is burnt in an incinerator to make heat to boil water, etc.

If the Egg Laying CAFO is using a liquid manure system, the technique will probably use anaerobic digestion to produce methane to produce electricity through microturbines.
Neither of these techniques is great on the technical/environmental side. But, in the context of this current communication, they are horrible.

This manure-to-energy approach is NOT commercially viable and often relies on heavy government investment/subsidy to work.
In effect what these schemes becomes are taxpayer subsidies to CAFOs for manure disposal.
The Sierra Club's Water Campaign explicitedly demands that CAFOs pay all the real costs of their production, particularly with regard to the environment.
That is one of the reasons we pursue the Clean Water Act enforcement lawsuits.
I am opposed to ANY government subsidy for any kind of CAFO/industrial food production.
In a time when Michigan is closing libraries for lack of state funds, how can we subsidize this inhumane and destructive industry?

Chris Bedford
West Michigan Center for Economic Security
#6543 Hancock Road
Montague, MI 49437
231-893-3937 (o)
231-670-4817 (c)

"Michigan is ground-zero in the struggle to build a sustainable food system." -- Michael Hamm, C.S. Mott Group, Michigan State University

On Mar 24, 2005, at 8:22 PM, Jan O'Connell wrote:

Enviro-Mich message from Jan O'Connell <jan.oconnell@juno.com>

HI Anne,

I can find out more info on this but I was talking last week with a
friend that runs a business to promote Sustainable businesses. He
told me of some new process that he's helping work on....to turn
chicken wastes into energy. I wasn't able to talk to him long but
he specifically mentioned Herbruck's as being one of the businesses
he was trying to assist in this so-called sustainable process. My ears
were atuned because years ago this was one of the first CAFO's I
reviewed, took pictures of when I was reviewing CAFO's with the
two interns working with me on CAFO's.

Back then (I believe) it was about 4 years ago....they were adding their
3rd barn and heavens...I think when I drove to Lansing a couple weeks
ago they were starting to build their 10th barn.

Anne, do you want more info on this....turning chicken waste into energy
process and if they were planning to handle all of Herbruck's waste
in this fashion?

Jan O'Connell

On Thu, 24 Mar 2005 20:00:47 -0500 "Anne Woiwode"
<anne.woiwode@sierraclub.org> writes:
Enviro-Mich message from "Anne Woiwode"

Herbruck's is a massive chicken concentrated animal feeding
operation (CAFO)
with one of its massive facilities easily seen on the southwestern
corner of
I-96 and the Ionia exit.

There is a DEEP irony to this timing -- the Attorney General of
Oklahoma has
just filed a notice of intent to sue that appears to list almost
poultry CAFO in the state giving them ALL 90 day's notice of the
intent to
sue under the Clean Water Act because, as the Letter of Intent
states, "The
Poultry Integrators have contributed to the handling, storage
disposal of solid and/or hazardous waste in a manner that may or
present an imminent and substantial endangerment to human health and
environment in the Illinois River Watershed" (IRW).

The Letter of intent explains that these poultry operations,
egg-laying facilities, "generate hundreds of thousands of tons of
waste" which "constitute solid and/or hazardous waste pursuant"
federal law, and that "Since approximately 1980, it has been the
practice of
the Poultry Integrators to dispose of this waste on lands within the
resulting in the release of this waste and associated pollutants
into soils,
groundwater and surface waters of the IRW -- a practice which may
and does
present an imminent and substantial endangerment of human health and
environment in the IRW" in violation of federal law and regulations.
waste is identified as containing phosphorous and phosphorous
nitrogen and nitrogen compounds, arsenic and arsenic compounds, zinc
zinc compounds, copper and copper compounds, hormones, antibiotics,
microbial pathogens.

Sierra Club last month sent a letter to the MEDC protesting other
support of
CAFOs, specifically tax exempt bonds for two dairy CAFOs and support
roads for other dairy CAFOs. We have requested the MEDC to end its
of supporting CAFO expansion in Michigan. In a separate email I
will post
our arguments to the MEDC for ending this practice.

Anne Woiwode
Sierra Club

Anyone know anything about the nature of the Herbruck Poultry Ranch,
project listed below (Ionia County) that MDOT is supporting?

Contact: Benjamin Kohrman 517-335-3084
Agency: Transportation

Governor Granholm announces transportation economic development
to support more than 2,000 jobs Mar 24, 2005

March 24, 2005 - - Gov. Jennifer M. Granholm today announced
that more
than 2,000 jobs will be created or retained in Michigan as the
result of
$6,451,751 in state-funded transportation investments that will
more than $523 million in private sector development.

The Michigan Department of Transportation (MDOT) is partnering with
governments and other state agencies to provide a total of
$29,430,478 in
transportation-related investments for targeted road projects that
support Michigan jobs and fuel economic growth.

"These projects will put people to work this year and support
jobs with important road projects in Michigan communities," Granholm
"We are pleased to partner with local governments and industry to
state transportation dollars where they will create jobs today and
Michigan's economy."

Funded with Transportation Economic Development Fund (TEDF) grants,
improvements include resurfacing, reconstruction, widening, road
and other upgrades considered crucial to economic development. The
TEDF was
enacted by the Michigan Legislature in 1987 to assist in the funding
highway, road, and street projects necessary to support economic
growth. The
Category A or "Target Industries Program" is specifically aimed at
transportation improvements to encourage private investments in
that create or retain jobs.

MDOT collaborated with the Michigan Economic Development
Corporation (MEDC)
to select transportation improvement projects in six counties:
Huron, Ionia,
Kalamazoo Oakland, Otsego, and Washtenaw. These projects combined
result in 2,115 jobs.

"Transportation moves the economy and improves quality of life,"
said State
Transportation Director Gloria J. Jeff. "MDOT is proud to partner
private industry and state and local agencies to invest in strategic
improvements that will grow Michigan's economy today and,
benefit businesses and motorists for years to come."

The TEDF will fund $6,451,751 of the $29,430,478 in work. State and
matches will total $22,978,727 (78 percent) of the transportation

"For every state transportation dollar spent on these public road
improvements, the private sector is investing $81. The TEDF is
clearly one
of our most effective tools for growing Michigan's economy," said


Ionia County

The Ionia County Road Commission will upgrade Portland Road to
support the
expansion of Herbruck Poultry Ranch, Inc. Herbruck's Portland Road
is an integrated egg-laying operation. Shipments of incoming feed
outgoing products must use Portland Road to access the facility,
which is
beyond its normal service life and currently subject to seasonal
restrictions. The project will include crushing and shaping,
surfacing, and new aggregate road shoulders, which will allow for
elimination of seasonal weight restrictions. Herbruck Poultry Ranch
investing $25,000,000 to expand its poultry production facilities,
will create 50 new jobs by 2007. The cost of the project is
including $380,000 in TEDF Category A funds, $132,000 from the Ionia
Road Commission, and $40,000 from Herbruck Poultry Ranch, Inc.


ENVIRO-MICH: Internet List and Forum for Michigan Environmental
and Conservation Issues and Michigan-based Citizen Action.
Archives at

Postings to: enviro-mich@great-lakes.net For info, send email
majordomo@great-lakes.net with a one-line message body of "info

ENVIRO-MICH: Internet List and Forum for Michigan Environmental
and Conservation Issues and Michigan-based Citizen Action. Archives at

Postings to: enviro-mich@great-lakes.net For info, send email to
majordomo@great-lakes.net with a one-line message body of "info enviro-mich"